Z szacunku do... Z doświadczeń badań transdyscyplinarnych

Dorota Kuncewicz; Wojciech Kruszewski

doi:10.18290/rh.2017.65.1-10

Dorota Kuncewicz The Maria Grzegorzewska University
Wojciech Kruszewski The John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin, Faculty of Humanities

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18290/rh.2017.65.1-10

Keywords: transdisciplinary research; scientific review; qualitative psychology; literary studies and psychology

Abstract

The presented article concerns the evaluation of a transdisciplinary study carried out by researchers from two different disciplines: psychology and literary studies. The team working on this project analyzed adults’ narrations about their lives, applying the method of literary study analysis. At the stage of interpretation we used an original method of qualitative research in psychology. The effect of this research was subject to review by a psychologist, who declared that our article had been rated in accordance with the principles of psychological research assessment. This article presents the areas of misunderstanding which result from the relationship between a study and a review constructed in the aforementioned respective manners. We point out the main principles, which, in our opinion, should accompany people reviewing studies of a transdisciplinary nature.

References

Bachtin M., Problemy poetyki Dostojewskiego, tłum. N. Modzelewska, Warszawa 1970.

Bartmiński J., Droga naukowa Anny Wierzbickiej. Od składni polskiej prozy renesansowej do semantyki międzykulturowej, „Teksty Drugie” 2011, nr 1/2, s. 218-238.

Bonecki M., Interpretacja humanistyczna a teoretyczna rekonstrukcja kultury, „Filo-Sofija” 2011, nr 1, s. 189-211.

Evans J.E., Electronic Publication and the Narrowing of Science and Scholarship, „Science” 2008, nr 321, s. 395-399.

Fichna J., Osajda K., Pieniądz A., Skowron B., Interdyscyplinarność z perspektywy młodych badaczy, „Nauka” 2015, nr 4, s. 161-183.

Głosy w sprawie interdyscyplinarności. Socjologowie, filozofowie i inni o pojęciach, podejściach i swych doświadczeniach, red. J. Kurczewska, M. Lejzerowicz, Warszawa 2014.

Heller M., Wszechświat jest tylko drogą, Kraków 2012.

Hirsch Hadorn G., Pohl Ch., Methodology of Transdisciplinary Knowlegde, [w:] Unity of Knowledge. In Transdisciplinary Research for Sustainability, t. II: Methodology of Transdisciplinary Research, red. G. Hirsch Hadorn, Ch. Pohl, M. Scheringer, Oxford 2009, s. 1-29.

Horlick-Jones T., Sime J., Living on the Border. Knowledge, Risk and Transdisciplinarity, „Futures” 2004, nr 36, s. 441-456.

Kemp S.P., Nurius P.S., Preparing Emerging Doctoral Scholars for Transdisciplinary Research. A Developmental Approach, „Journal of Teaching in Social Work” 2015, nr 1-2, s. 131-150.

Klein J.T., Evaluation of Interdisciplinary and Transdisciplinary Research. A Literature Review, „American Journal of Preventive Medicine” 2008, nr 2, s. 116-123.

Kuncewicz D., Kruszewski W., Zasim A., Życie z szablonu CV. Doświadczenie pokoleniowe w narracjach młodych dorosłych, „Kultura i Edukacja” 2016, nr 3, s. 64-85.

Kuncewicz D., Sokołowska E., Sobkowicz J., Parents’ and Their Adult Children’s Narrations on Upbringing, „Annals of Psychology” 2014, nr 4, s. 775-791.

Kuncewicz D., Sokołowska E., Sobkowicz J., Which Literary Theory Tools Can a Psyhologist Use for Interpreting Language Communication?, „Polish Journal of Applied Psychology” 2014, nr 4, s. 71-94, DOI: 10.1515/pjap-2015-0022.

Leavy P., Essentials of Transdisciplinary Research. Using Problem-Centered Methodologies, Walnut Creek 2011.

Liu Z., Reading Behavior in the Digital Environment, „Journal of Documentation” 2005, nr 61, s. 700-712.

Nycz R., Kulturowa natura, słaby profesjonalizm. Kilka uwag o przedmiocie poznania literackiego i statusie dyskursu literaturoznawczego, [w:] Kulturowa teoria literatury. Główne pojęcia i problemy, red. M.P. Markowski, R. Nycz, Kraków 2012, s. 5-38.

Rademaekers J.K., Is WAC/WID Ready for the Transdisciplinary Research University?, „Across the Disciplines” 2015, nr 2, http://wac.colostate.edu/atd/articles/rademaekers 2015.cfm.

Sławiński J., Teksty i teksty, Warszawa 1990.

Thompson M.A., Owen S., Lindsay J.M., Leonard G.S., Cronin S.J., Scientist and Stakeholder Perspectives of Transdisciplinary Research. Early Attitudes, Expectations, and Tensions, „Environmental Science & Policy” 2017, nr 74, s. 30-39. DOI: 10.1016/j.envsci.2017.04.006.

Wickson F., Carew A.L., Russell A.W., Transdisciplinary Research. Characteristics, Quandaries and Quality, „Futures” 2006, nr 38, s. 1046-1059.

Wierzbicka A., Słowa klucze. Różne języki – różne kultury, tłum. I. Duraj-Nowosielska, Warszawa 2016.

Out of Respect for ... On the Experience of Transdisciplinary Research

Abstract

References