Does the Pauline Claim to be “in Christ” Represent Uniformity in Christ-followers?

Antonio Magnante

Antonio Magnante Tangaza University College, Nairobi

Keywords: Sant Paul; uniformity of Church

Abstract

As an apostle and theologian Paul deserves to be discovered. He is really complex and multifaceted. To deal with him is always a challenge and one has to accept it in order to discover the depth of his theology. Since I started dealing with him professionally I have been haunted by a question: Did Paul cease to be a Jew after his conversion experience or continue to perceive himself as a member of his own Jewish lineage? In other words, how did he think he was after his experience along the Damascus road?

Most likely the best way to solve the problem is to discuss the consequences of his conversion experience, even though nobody knows what really happened to Paul along the Damascus road. Certainly it was not a moral conversion. He was not in need of a new ethical way of life, so his conversion was not spiritual. It was rather theological, which implied “a reversal or transvaluation of values”, that led Paul to revisit radically the basic system of values and commitments of his traditions.

References

Byrne B.: “Interpreting Romans Theologically in a Post-`New Perspective' Perspective”, HTR 62 (2001) 227-241.

Campbell W. S.: “Universality and Particularity in Paul's Understanding and Strategy of Mission”, in Paul as Missionary. Identity, Activity, Theology and Practice, ed. by Trevor J. Burke-Brians S. Rosner, London: T &T Clark 2011.

Cantalamessa R.: Life in Christ. A Spiritual Commentary on the Letter to the Romans, St. Pauls: Mumbai 2003.

Cosgrove Ch. H.: “Did Paul Value Ethnicity?”, CBQ 68(2006), p. 268-290.

Dowing F. G.: “A Cynic Preparation for Paul's Gospel for Jew and Greek, Slave and Free, Male and Female”, NTS 42 (1996), p. 454-462.

Dunn J. D.G.: “Who did Paul Think He was?”, NTS 45(1999), p. 174-193.

Dunn J. D.G.: The Theology of Paul the Apostle, London: T & T Clark 1998.

Dunn J. D.G.: Jesus, Paul and the Gospels, Grand Rapids: William B. Erdmans 2011.

Ellis P. F.: Seven Pauline Letters, Collegeville: The Liturgical Press 1982.

Esler P.: Conflict and Identity in Romans: The Social Setting of Paul's Letter, Minneapolis: Fortress Press 2003.

Fitzmyer J.A.: Paul and his Theology. A Brief Sketch, Prentice-Hall: A Simon & Schuster Company 1989.

Gager J.G.: “Some Notes on Paul's Conversion”, NTS 27(1980-81), p. 697-704.

Hays J. D.: “Paul and the Multi-Ethnic First-Century World: Ethnicity and Christian Identity”, in Paul as Missionary. Identity, Activity, Theology and Practice, ed. by Trevor J. Burke-Brians S. Rosner, London: T &T Clark 2011, p. 76-87.

Jeremias J.: “The Key to Pauline Theology”, Expository Times 76(1964/65), p. 27-30.

Jewett R.: “The Law and the Coexistence of Jews and Gentiles in Romans”, Int XXXIX(1985), p. 341-356.

Keck L. E.: Paul and His Letters. Proclamation Commentaries, Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1979.

KimberBuell D.: “Rethinking the Relevance of the Race for Early Christian Self-identification”, HTR 94.4 (2001), p. 449-476.

KimberBuell D.: and Johnson Hodge, C. “The Politics Interpretation: The Rhetoric od Race and Ethnicity in Paul”, JBL 123/2 (2004), p. 235-251.

Lyonnet S.: “St. Paul: Liberty and Law”, The Bridge 4(1962), p. 229-251.

Longenecker R. N.: Galatians, WBC 41, Nashville: Thomas Nelson Publishers 1990.

Longenecker R. N.: Paul Apostle of Liberty, New York: Harper & Row 1964.

Martyn J. L.: Galatians, AB 33A, New York: Doubleday, 1997.

Miller J. C.: “Paul and his Ethnicity: Reframing the Categories”, in Paul as Missionary. Identity, Activity, Theology and Practice, ed. by Trevor J. Burke-Brians S. Rosner, London: T &T Clark 2011.

Menoud Ph. H.: “Revelation and Tradition”, Int 7(1953), p. 131-141.

Moo D.J.: “Paul and the Law in the Last Ten Years”, SJT 40(1987), p. 287-307.

Nardoni E.: “The Concept of Charism in Paul”, CBQ 55(1993) 68-80.

Penna R.: Paul the Apostle. Wisdom and Folly of the Cross, Vol 2, Collegeville: The Liturgical Press 1966.

Penna R.: Vangelo e Inculturazione. Studi sul rapporto tra rivelazione e cultura nel Nuovo Testamento, Cinisello Balsamo: San Paolo 2001.

Romanello S.: L'identità dei credenti in Cristo secondo Paolo, Bologna: EDB 2011.

Ralston T. J.: “The Theological Significance of Paul's Conversion”, Bibliotheca Sacra 147(1990), p. 198-215.

Sanders E.: Paul and Palestinian Judaism, Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1977.

Schnackenburg R.: Baptism in the Thought of St. Paul. A Study in Pauline Theology, New York: Herder & Herder 1964.

Senior D.: “The Mission Theology of Paul”, in D. Senior-C. Stuhlmueller, The Biblical Foundations for Mission, New York: Orbis Book 1983.

Vanhoye A.: Lettera ai Galati. Nuova versione, introduzione e comment, I Libri Biblici, Milano: Paoline 2000.

Wood H.G.: “The Conversion of Paul: Its Nature, Antecedents and Consequences”, NTS 1(1954-55), p. 276-282.

Wedderburn A.J.M.: “The Body of Christ and Related Concepts in 1Corinthians”, Scotish Journal of Theology 24(1971), p. 74-96.