Addressing Russian Threat. Changes to Defence Policies of the Nordic States After 2014

Keywords: Nordic states, defence, total defence, defence cooperation, Russia 2014-

Abstract

The substantial deterioration of the security environment after Russian aggression against Ukraine and the illegal annexation of Crimea in 2014 was a catalyst for significant changes in the Nordic states’ approach to security and defence. Common perceptions of the Russian threat focused defence policies of the Nordic states around rebuilding total defence capabilities, which would combine military and civilian efforts. Besides these efforts to reinforce national capacity to defend against an armed attack, the Nordic states increased regional security and defence cooperation, along with cooperation with NATO, the EU and the United States. The article explores the developments in defence policies of the Nordic states that were a result of changes in the security environment caused by Russian aggression against Ukraine and the illegal annexation of Crimea in 2014. It tries to discuss differences in national threat assessment, and then compare and contrast unique national approaches to defence policies that were adopted by the Nordic states. The conclusion conceptualizes unique features of the Nordic approach to defence stemming from the common threat to their security.

References

Bailes A., Ólafsson K. (2014), Developments in Icelandic Security Policy, 18 December, Reykjavík: Sigillum Universitatis Islandiae.

Chivvis Ch. S. (2016), NATO’s Northeastern Flank — Emerging Opportunities for Engagement, Santa Monica: RAND Corporation.

Deen B., Kruijver K., Stoetman A., Zandee, D. (2020), European Strategic Autonomy in Security and Defence. Now the Going Gets Tough, It’s Time to Get Going, Clingendael Reports, Den Haag: Netherlands Institute of International Relations.

Drent M., Meijnders M. (2015), Multi-year Defence Agreements A Model for Modern Defence?, September, Hague: Clingendael Institute.

Finland M. o. D. o. (2018), Trilateral Statement of Intent among the Department of Defense of the United States of America and the Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Finland and the Ministry of Defence of the Kingdom of Sweden, Helsinki, Ministry of Defence of Finland.

Friis, K. (2018), Norway: NATO in the North?, [in:] N. Vanaga, T. Rostoks (red.), Deterring Russia in Europe: Defence Strategies for Neighbouring States, London: Routledge, s. 136.

Government Offices of Sweden (2018), https://www.government.se/articles/2018/05/development-of-modern-total-defence/ [Accessed: 21.05.2021].

Government of Sweden (2020), 18 December, https://www.government.se/government-policy/defence/objectives-for-swedish-total-defence-2021-2025---government-bill-totalforsvaret-20212025/ [Accessed: 3.02.2021].

Himberg P. (2019), This Was the Spirit of the Winter War and a Miracle Through the Eyes of a Contemporary, https://yle.fi/aihe/artikkeli/2019/11/29/talvisota [Accessed: 20.02.2021].

IISS (2021), Chapter Four: Europe, The Military Balance, 121(1), s. 114.

Larsen J. (2020), A Small State Addressing Big Problems, Copenhagen: Danish Institute for International Studies.

Matti P., Iso-Markku T., Jokela J. (2020), Finnish Foreign Policy During EU Membership Unlocking the EU’s Security Potential, Helsinki: Finnish Institute of International Affairs.

Merritt P. (2020), Norway Prepares for the Future: Examining the Long Term Defence Plan 2020, https://finabel.org/norway-prepares-for-the-future-examining-the-long-term-defence-plan-2020/ [Accessed: 25.06.2021].

Ministry for Foreign Affairs of Iceland (2019), Together Towards a Sustainable Arctic. Iceland’s Arctic Council Chairmanship 2019-2021, https://www.government.is/library/01-Ministries/Ministry-for-Foreign-Affairs/PDF-skjol/Arctic%20Council%20-%20Iceland's%20Chairmanship%202019-2021.pdf [Accessed: 12.03.2021].

Ministry of Defence (2020), Substantial investment in total defence, https://www.government.se/press-releases/2020/10/substantial-investment-in-total-defence/ [Accessed: 4.07.2021].

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark (2018), Foreign and Security Policy Strategy 2019–2020, November, Copenhagen.

Møller J. (2019), Trilateral Defence Cooperation in the North: An Assessment of Interoperability Between Norway, Sweden and Finland, Defence Studies, 19(3), s. 250–251.

NATO (2020), NATO Defence Planning Capability Review 2019/2020. Denmark. Overview, 14 October, Brussels, NATO Document C-M(2020)0026 (DK-OVERVIEW).

Nikel D. (2020), Sweden to Increase Defense Spending by 40% Amid Russia Fears, 16 October, https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidnikel/2020/10/16/sweden-to-increase-defense-spending-by-40-amid-russia-fears/?sh=697e66e667ba [Accessed: 3.02.2021].

NORDEFCO (2018), Nordic Defence Cooperation Vision 2025, https://www.nordefco.org/Files/nordefco-vision-2025-signed.pdf [Accessed: 23.02.2021].

Norwegian Ministry of Defence (2020), The defence of Norway: Capability and readiness. Long Term Defence Plan 2020, https://www.regjeringen.no/contentassets/3a2d2a3cfb694aa3ab4c6cb5649448d4/long-term-defence-plan-norway-2020---english-summary.pdf [Accessed: 23.06.2021].

Parliament of Finland (2014), Long-Term Challenges of Defence. Final report of the parliamentary assessment group (summary), 1 October, Helsinki, Parliamentary Office 5/2014.

Parliament of Iceland (2016), Parliamentary Resolution on a National Security Policy for Iceland, 13 April, Reykjavik, Parliamentary document 1166—Case No. 327.

Prime Minister’s Office (2016), Government Report on Finnish Foreign and Security Policy, Helsinki, Prime Minister’s Office Publications 9/2016.

Prime Minister’s Office [Finland] (2017), Government’s Defence Report, Helsinki, Prime Minister’s Office Publications 7/2017.

Prime Minister’s Office [Sweden] (2017), National Security Strategy, Stockholm, Gullers Grupp.

Regeringskanliet (2020), Summary of Government bill ‘Totalförsvaret 2021–2025’ (Total defence 2021–2025), 17 December, Stockholm, Government Offices.

SHAPE (no date), Exercise Trident Juncture 18—Total Defence Concept, https://shape.nato.int/news-archive/2018/exercise-trident-juncture-18-total-defence-concept [Accessed: 24.06.2021].

SLD.info (2020), Norway Releases its Long Term Defence Plan, 2020: Resilience as a Core Defense Capability, https://sldinfo.com/2020/04/norway-releases-its-long-term-defence-plan-2020-resilience-as-a-core-defense-capability/ [Accessed: 24.02.2021].

Stormark, K. (2017), Russian forces exercised attack on Svalbard, https://www.aldrimer.no/russian-forces-exercised-attack-on-svalbard/ [Accessed: 18.06.2021].

Sweden’s Defence Policy 2016 to 2020 (2015), s. 2, Stockholm, Government of Sweden.

The Office of the United States Trade Representative (1951), Agreement Between the United States of America and Iceland, Washington.

Tillotson H. (1993), Finland at Peace and War 1918–1993, Norwich: Russell Publishing Ltd.

Wither J. (2020), Back to the Future? Nordic Total Defence Concepts, Defence Studies, 20(1), s. 63.

Published
2021-12-16
Section
Articles