Przyczynek do analizy wartości poznawczej systemów logiki sprawczości

Robert Trypuz

Robert Trypuz Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II, Wydział Filozofii

Słowa kluczowe: sprawczość, działanie, Davidson, Belnap, STIT

Abstrakt

In this article the two approaches towards representation of action, namely the Anselmian and Davidsonian ones, are described and compared. Especially the ontological commitment of the two approaches are brought to light. The central problem of the paper is the question of adequacy of these approaches to representation of actions.

Bibliografia

Anscombe [1957] – E. Anscombe, Intention, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University 1957.

Bach [1980] – K. Bach, Actions are not events, „Mind” (89) 1980, s. 114-120.

Belnap i in. [2001] – N. Belnap, M. Perloff, M. Xu, Facing the future: agents and choices in our indeterminist world, Oxford: Oxford University Press 2001.

Bratman [1987] – M. E. Bratman, Intention, Plans, and Practical Reason, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press 1987.

Chisholm [1969] – R. Chisholm, Some puzzles about agency, [w:] The logical way of doing things, red. K. Lambert, Yale University Press, New Haven 1969, s. 199-217.

Comrie [1976] – B. Comrie, Aspect: An Introduction to Verbal Aspect and Related Problems, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1976.

Davidson [1966] – D. Davidson, The Logical Form of Action Sentences, [w:] The Logic of Decision and Action, red. N. Rescher, University of Pittsburgh Press 1966, s. 81-95.

Davidson [1991] – D. Davidson, Essays on Actions and Events, Oxford: Clarendon Press 1991.

Dowty [1986] – D. Dowty, The effects of aspectual classes on the temporal structure of discourse: semantics or pragmatics? „Linguistics and Philosophy”, (9) 1986, s. 37-61.

Frankfurt [1978] – H. Frankfurt, The problem of action, [w:] The Philosophy of Action, red. A. Mele, Oxfort University Press 2003.

Ginet [1990] – C. Ginet, On Action, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press 1990.

Goldman [1970] – A. Goldman, A Theory of Human Action, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N. J. 1970.

Henry [1953] – D. P. Henry, St. Anselm and the Varieties of Doing, „Theoria” (19), s. 178-185.

Henry [1967] – D. P. Henry, Logic of Saint Anselm, Oxford: Oxford University Press 1967.

Hornsby [1980] – J. Hornsby, Actions, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul 1980.

Horty [2001] – J. F. Horty, Agency and Deontic Logic, Oxford: Oxford University Press 2001.

Kenny [1963] – A. Kenny, Action, Emotion and Will, New York: The Humanities Press, Inc 1963.

Lowe [2002] – E. J. Lowe, A Survey of Metaphysics, Oxford: Oxford University Press 2002.

Mele [1992] – A. Mele, Springs of Action: Understanding Intentional Behavior, New York: Oxford University Press 1992.

Moens, Steedman [1988] – M. Moens, M. Steedman, Temporal Ontology and Temporal Reference „Computational Linguistics”, 14 (2) 1988, s. 15–28.

Mourelatos [1978] – A. P. D. Mourelatos, Events, processes, and states, „Linguistics and Philosophy” (2) 1978, s. 415-434.

O’Shaughnessy [1973] – B. O’Shaughnessy, Trying (as the mental ‘pineal gland’), „Journal of Philosophy” (70) 1973, s. 365-386.

Searle [2001] – J. R. Searle, Rationality in Action, The MIT Press 2001.

Thomson [1977] – J. J. Thomson, Acts and Other Events, Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press 1977.

Troquard i in. [2006] – N. Troquard, R. Trypuz, L. Vieu, Towards an ontology of agency and action: From STIT to OntoSTIT+, [w:] Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference FOIS 2006, red. B. Bennett, C. Fellbaum, Baltimore, Maryland (USA), Listopad 9-11, IOS Press 2006, s. 179-190.

Trypuz [2007] – R. Trypuz, Formal Ontology of Action: a unifying approach. Rozprawa doktorska, Università degli Studi di Trento, ICT International Doctorate School 2007.

Trypuz, Vieu [2007] – R. Trypuz, L. Vieu, An Ontology of the Aspectual Classes of Actions, [w:] ILCLI International Workshop on Logic and Philosophy of Knowledge, Communication and Action (LogKCA-07), red. X. Arrazola, J. M. Larrazabal, University of the Basque Country Press 2007, s. 393-409.

Trypuz i in. [2007] – R. Trypuz, E. Lorini, L. Vieu, Solving Bratman’s video game puzzle in two formalisms, [w:] ILCLI International Workshop on Logic and Philosophy of Knowledge, Communication and Action (LogKCA-07), red. X. Arrazola, J. M. Larrazabal, University of the Basque Country Press 2007, s. 411-426.

Vendler [1957] – Z. Vendler, Verbs and times, „Philosophical Review” (46) 1957, s. 143-160.

von Wright [1963] – G. H. von Wright, Norm and Action, New York: The Humanities Press 1963.

Walton [1976a] – D. Walton, Logical Form and Agency, „Philosophical Studies” (29) 1976, s. 75-89.

Walton [1976b] – D. Walton, St. Anselm and the Logical Syntax of Agency, „Franciscan Studies” (36) 1976, s. 298–312.