The Supreme Court of the United States During the War of Secession and the Reconstruction

  • Grzegorz Górski Catholic University of Lublin
Keywords: the Supreme Court of the United States, the War of Secession, Reconstruction

Abstract

The period of the War of Secession and the so-called Reconstruction was a time of a great trial for the Superior Court of the United States. The negative consequences of the verdict in D. Scott’s case shook the authority of the tribunal. Even when in the Court Republicans outnumbered Democrats and they tried not to come into further conflicts with the leadership of their party with their verdicts, restoring the prestige of the Court was difficult. It should be stressed, however, that generally avoiding serious clashes, especially with the party colleagues, the Court emphasized its position as the ultimate verifier of conformity of legislative solutions with the constitutional provisions. Although it was forced to defend its position, without any means to enforce its will or opinion, it kept the authority of the last resort in this field. Hence, even if it usually confirmed the solutions advocated by the Republicans, it still influenced their radicalism, preventing extreme conceptions even at the stage of their elaboration by the Congress. This was due to the fact that the Republicans also understood that in a longer perspective keeping up a conflict with the Court (in which they outnumbered the Democrats anyway) and weakening its position does not serve well either their particular party affairs or, the more so, the authority and stability of the whole federal government. All this resulted in the Supreme Court taking the way of a slow reconstruction of its former position.

References

Bełz A.: Reconstructing the Union, Ithaca, N.Y. 1969.

Burgess W.: Reconstruction and the Constitution, New York 1902.

Churchill W.: A History of the English Speaking People, vol. 4, London 1958.

Fairman Ch.: History of the Supreme Court of the United States: Reconstruction and Reunion 1864-1888, Part One, New York 1971.

Górski G.: Sprawa Dreda Scotta. Przyczynek do dziejów amerykańskiego konstytucjonalizmu. Czasy Nowożytne, Toruń 2002.

Maine H.: Popular Government, London 1886.

Moore A.: A Digest of International Law, vol. 7 (1906).

Stampp K. M.: The Era of Reconstruction: 1865 to 1877, New York 1965.

The Collected Works of Abraham Lincoln, vol. 5, New Brunswick-New York 1953.

The Diary of Gideon Welles, New York 1960.

The Struggle for Equality: Abolitionists and the Negro in the Civil War and

Reconstruction, Princeton 1964.

The Supreme Court Justices. Illustrated Biographies 1789-1995, [bmw.] 1995.

The Works of John C. Calhoun, vol. 6, New York 1857.

Warren E.: The Great Rights, [bmw.] 1963.

Published
2019-11-13
Section
Articles