Anti-Naturalistic Arguments From Reason

Keywords: evolution, identity theory, naturalism, reason, self-defeat, theism


This paper discusses a wide range of anti-naturalistic argument from reason due to Balfour, Haldane, Joad, Lewis, Taylor, Moreland, Plantinga, Reppert, and Hasker. I argue that none of these arguments poses a serious challenge to naturalists who are identity theorists. Further, I argue that some of these arguments do not even pose prima facie plausible challenges to naturalism. In the concluding part of my discussion, I draw attention to some distinctive differences between Hasker’s anti-naturalistic arguments and the other anti-naturalistic arguments mentioned above.


Anderson, Tina, and Perry Hendricks. 2020. “Does the Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism Defeat God’s Beliefs?” Sophia 59:489–99.

Anscombe, Elizabeth. 1948. “C. S. Lewis’s Rewrite of Chapter III of Miracles.” In C. S. Lewis and His Circle: Essays and Memoirs from the Oxford C. S. Lewis Society, edited by Roger White, Judith E. Wolfe, and Brendan N. Wolfe, 15–24. New York: Oxford University Press.

Balfour, Arthur J. 1877. “A Speculation about Evolution.” Fortnightly Review 28:698–704.

Balfour, Arthur J. 1879. A Defence of Philosophical Doubt: Being an Essay on the Foundations of Belief. London: Longmans, Green & Co.

Balfour, Arthur J. 1895. The Foundations of Belief: Being Notes Introductory to the Study of Theology New York: Longmans, Green & Co.

Beilby, James K. 1997. “Is Evolutionary Naturalism Self-Defeating?” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 42:69–78

Beilby, James K., ed. 2002. Naturalism Defeated? Essays on Plantinga’s Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Beilby, James K. 2003. “Plantinga’s Pox on Metaphysical Naturalism.” Philosophia Christi 5:131–42.

Cantens, Bernardo. 2006. “Cognitive Faculties and Evolutionary Naturalism.” Proceedings of the American Catholic Philosophical Association 80:201–8.

Chesterton, Gilbert K. 1908. Orthodoxy. London: Dodd, Mean & Co.

Chesterton, Gilbert K. 1933. St. Thomas Aquinas. London: Sheed and Ward.

Childers, G. 2011. “What’s Wrong with the Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism?” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 69:193–204.

Churchland, Paul. 2009. “Is Evolutionary Naturalism Self-Defeating?” Philo 12:135–41.

Collin, James H. 2013. “Semantic Inferentialism and the Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” Philosophy Compass 8:846–56.

Cross, Troy. n.d. “On Plantinga on Belief in Naturalism.” Ms.

DePoe, John M. 2013. “The Self-Defeat of Naturalism: A Critical Comparison of Alvin Plantinga and C. S. Lewis.” Christian Scholars Review 44:9–26.

Drange, Theodore. 2003. “Several Unsuccessful Formulations of the Argument from Reason.” Philosophia Christi 5:35–52.

Draper, Paul. 2007. “In Defence of Sensible Naturalism.”

Fales, Evan. 1996. “Plantinga’s Case against Naturalistic Epistemology.” Philosophy of Science 63:433–51.

Fitelson, Branden, and Elliott Sober. 1998. “Plantinga’s Probability Arguments against Evolutionary Naturalism.” Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 79:115–29.

Goetz, Stewart. 2013. “The Argument from Reason.” Philosophia Christi 15:47–62.

Graber, Abraham, and Luke Golemon. 2020. “Plantinga Redux: Is the Scientific Realist Committed to the Rejection of Naturalism?” Sophia 59:395–412.

Graham, Peter J. 2011. “Intelligent Design and Selective History: Two Sources of Purpose and Plan.” Oxford Studies in Philosophy of Religion 3:67–88.

Haldane, J. B. S. 1929. Possible Worlds and Other Essays. London: Chatto and Windus.

Hasker, William. 1971. “Theories, Analogies and Criteria.” American Philosophical Quarterly 8:242–56.

Hasker, William. 1981. “The God of the Philosophers.” Philosophical Review 90:621.

Hasker, William. 1988. “Yes, God has Beliefs.” Religious Studies 24:385–94.

Hasker, William. 1992. “Evolution and Alvin Plantinga.” Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith 44:150–62.

Hasker, William. 1993a. “Christian Philosophy.” Faith and Philosophy 10:107–12.

Hasker, William. 1993b. “Should Natural Science Include Revealed Truth. A Response to Plantinga.” Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith 45:57–59.

Hasker, William. 1994. “Gale on God: The Return of Philo?” Dialogue 33:685–91.

Hasker, William. 1998a. “The Foundations of Theism: Scoring the Quinn-Plantinga Debate.” Faith and Philosophy 15:52–67.

Hasker, William. 1998b. “Swinburne’s Modal Argument for Dualism: Epistemically Circular.” Faith and Philosophy 15:366–70.

Hasker, William. 1998c. God, Time and Knowledge. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Hasker, William. 2001. The Emergent Self. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Hasker, William. 2002. “Is Christianity Probable? Swinburne’s Apologetic Programme.” Religious Studies 38:253–64.

Hasker, William. 2004. Providence, Evil and the Openness of God. New York: Routledge.

Hasker, William. 2005. “Analytic Philosophy of Religion” in Handbook of Philosophy of Religion, edited by William Wainwright, 421–26. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hasker, William. 2008a. “On Behalf of the Pagans and the Idolaters: A Response to Burrell.” Faith and Philosophy 25:197–204.

Hasker, William. 2008b. The Triumph of God over Evil. Downers Grove, IL: Intervarsity.

Hasker, William. 2009. “Intelligent Design.” Philosophy Compass 4:586–97.

Hasker, William. 2010. “All Too Sceptical Theism.” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 68:15–29.

Hasker, William. 2013a. “What is Naturalism? And Should We Be Naturalists?” Philosophia Christi 15:21–34.

Hasker, William. 2013b. Metaphysics and the Tri-Personal God. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hasker, William. 2016a. “How Christian Can Philosophy Be?” Roczniki Filozoficzne 64 (1): 21–40.

Hasker, William. 2016b. “Is Divine Simplicity a Mistake?” American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 90:699–725.

Hasker, William. 2016c. “Christ and the Shape of Philosophy: A Rejoinder to Moser.” Roczniki Filozoficzne 64 (4): 55–65.

Hasker, William. 2016d. Metaphysics: Constructing a World View. Downers Grove, IL: Intervarsity.

Hasker, William. 2018. “Responding to Challenges.” In Christian Philosophy: Conceptions, Continuations, Challenges, edited by J. Aaron Simmons, 286–304. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Heck, Joel. 2009. “From Vocal Agnostic to Reluctant Convert: C. S. Lewis and C. E. M. Joad.” Sehnsucht 3:11–32.

Hendricks, Perry. 2018. “Response to Wunder: Objective Probability, Non-Contingent Theism, and the EAAN.” Religious Studies 54:1–5.

Joad, C. E. M. 1932. Under the Fifth Rib. London: Faber & Faber.

Joad, C. E. M. 1933. Guide to Modern Thought. London: Faber & Faber.

Johnson, David K. 2015. “Con: Naturalism Undefeated.” In C. S. Lewis’ Christian Apologetics: Pro and Con, edited by Gregory Bassham, 91–103. Leiden: Brill.

Johnson, D. 2018. “Retiring the Argument from Reason.” Philosophia Christi 20:541–63.

Judge, Tony. 2012. Radio Philosopher: The Radical Life of Cyril Joad. Charleston: Alpha House.

Kim, Jaegwon. 1993. Supervenience and Mind. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Law, Stephen. 2011. “Plantinga’s Belief-Cum-Desire Argument Refuted.” Religious Studies 47:245–56.

Law, Stephen. 2012. “Naturalism, Evolution and True Belief.” Analysis 72:41–48.

Leahy, Brian. 2013. “Can Teleosemantics Deflect the EAAN?” Philosophia 41:221–38.

Lee, William. 2009. “Does Plantinga’s Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism Work?” Religious Studies 45 (1): 73–83.

Lemos, John. 2003. “A Defence of Naturalistic Naturalised Epistemology.” Crítica 35:49–63.

Lewis, C. S. 1947. Miracles. London: Collins. (Revised edition appeared in 1960.)

Menuge, Angus. 2003. “Beyond Skinnerian Creatures: A Defense of the Lewis and Plantinga Critiques of Evolutionary Naturalism.” Philosophia Christi 5:143–66.

Miller, Calum. 2015. “Response to Stephen Law on the Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” Philosophia 43:147–52.

Mirza, Omar. 2008. “A User’s Guide to the Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” Philosophical Studies 141:125–46.

Mirza, Omar. 2011. “The Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” Philosophy Compass 6:78–89.

Moon, Andrew. 2017. “Debunking Morality: Lessons from the EAAN Literature.” Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 98:208–26.

Moreland, J. P. 1987. Scaling the Secular City: A Defence of Christianity. Grand Rapids: Baker.

Nathan, Nicolas M. 1997. “Naturalism and Self-Defeat: Plantinga’s Version.” Religious Studies 33:135–42.

Nieminen, Petteri, Marten Boudry, Esko Ryökäs, and Anne-Mari Mustonen. 2017. “Biblical and Theistic Arguments against the Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” Zygon 52:9–23.

O’Connor, Timothy. 1994. “An Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism?” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 24:527–39.

Oppy, Graham. 2018. Naturalism and Religion. New York: Routledge.

Parsons, Keith M. 2000. “Further Reflections on the Argument from Reason.” Philo 3:90–102.

Peressini, Anthony M. 1998. “Naturalism, Evolution and Self-Defeat.” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 44:41–51.

Plantinga, Alvin. 1991. “An Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” Logos 12:27–48.

Plantinga, Alvin. 1992. “On Rejecting the Theory of Common Ancestry: A Reply to Hasker.” Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith 44:258–63.

Plantinga, Alvin. 1993. Warrant and Proper Function. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Plantinga, Alvin. 1999. “The Evolutionary Anti-Naturalism Argument.” In Philosophy of Religion: The Big Questions, edited by Eleonore Stump and Michael J. Murray, 6–25. London: Blackwell.

Plantinga, Alvin. 2004. “Evolution, Epiphenomenalism, Reductionism.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 68:602–19.

Plantinga, Alvin. 2009. “The Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism: An Initial Statement of the Argument.” In Philosophy after Darwin: Classic and Contemporary Readings, edited by Michael Ruse, 301. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Plantinga, Alvin. 2011a. Where the Conflict Really Lies: Science, Religion and Naturalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Plantinga, Alvin. 2011b. “Content and Natural Selection.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 83:435–58.

Plantinga, Alvin. 2014. “A New Argument against Materialism.” Philosophia Christi 14:7–9.

Reichenbach, Bruce R., and Adam W. Nugent. 2006. “Does Plantinga Have His Own Defeater?” Philosophia Christi 8:141–50.

Reiter, David. 2000. “Plantinga on the Epistemic Implications of Naturalism.” Journal of Philosophical Research 25:141–47.

Reppert, Victor. 1999. “The Argument from Reason.” Philo 2:33–45.

Reppert, Victor. 2000. “Reply to Parsons and Lippard on the Argument from Reason.” Philo 3:76–89.

Reppert, Victor. 2003. C. S. Lewis’ Dangerous Idea: In Defence of the Argument from Reason. Downers Grove, IL: Intervarsity Press.

Reppert, Victor. 2009. “The Argument from Reason.” In Companion to Natural Theology, edited by William Craig and J. P. Moreland, 344–90. Malden: Wiley-Blackwell.

Reppert, Victor. 2015. “The Argument from Reason Defended.” In C. S. Lewis Christian Apologetics: Pro and Con, edited by Gregory Bassham. Leiden: Brill.

Reppert, Victor. 2018. “Extending the Debate on the Argument from Reason.” Philosophia Christi 20:517–39.

Rickbaugh, Brandon, and Todd Buras. 2017. “The Argument from Reason and Mental Causal Drainage: A Reply to van Inwagen.” Philosophia Christi 19:381–99.

Robbins, J. Wesley. 1994. “Is Naturalism Irrational?” Faith and Philosophy 11:255–59.

Root, John D. 1980. “The Philosophical and Religious Thought of Arthur James Balfour.” Journal of British Studies 19:120–41.

Ryle, Gilbert. 1949. The Concept of Mind. London: Hutchinson.

Segal, Aaron, and Alvin Plantinga. 2010. “Response to Churchland.” Philo 13 (2): 201–7.

Slagle, Jim. 2015. “Plantinga’s Scepticism.” Philosophia 43:1133–45.

Slagle, Jim. 2016. The Epistemological Skyhook: Determinism, Naturalism and Self-Defeat. New York: Routledge.

Sosa, E. 2007. “Natural Theology and Naturalist Atheology: Plantinga’s Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” In Alvin Plantinga, edited by Deane-Peter Baker. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Talbott, William. 2016. “A New Reliability Defeater for Evolutionary Naturalism.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 93:538–64.

Taliaferro, Charles. 2010. “Lewis and Naturalism.” In Companion to C. S. Lewis, edited by Robert MacSwain and Michael Ward, 105–18. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Taliaferro, Charles. 2015. “Arthur James Balfour: Theism and Humanism.” In Lewis’ List, edited by David Werther. New York: Bloomsbury.

Taylor, Richard. 1963. Metaphysics. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.

Tedesco, Matthew. 2002. “Theism, Naturalism, Evolution, and the Probability of Reliable Cognitive Faculties: A Response to Plantinga.” Philo 5:235–41.

Thomas, Geoffrey. 1992. Cyril Joad. London: Birkbeck.

Thune, Mike. 2005. “Plantinga Untouched: A Response to Beilby on the Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” Philosophia Christi 7:157–68.

Thune, Mike. 2006. “Naturalism, Hope and Alethic Rationality.” Philo 9:5–11.

Vogelstein, Eric. 2004. “The Consistency of Plantinga’s Argument against Naturalism.” Philo 7:122–25.

Wielenberg, Erik K. 2002. “How to be an Alethically Rational Naturalist.” Synthese 131:81–98.

Wielenberg, Erik K. 2008. God and the Reach of Reason: C. S. Lewis, David Hume and Bertrand Russell. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Williams, Donald T. 2004. “Review: C. S. Lewis’ Dangerous Idea: In Defence of the Argument from Reason.” Philosophia Christi 6:375–77.

Wittwer, Silvan. 2010. “Naturalism, Evolution and Culture.” Swiss Philosophical Preprints.

Wunder, Tyler. 2008. “Anti-Naturalism and Proper Function.” Religious Studies 44:209–24.

Wunder, Tyler. 2015. “The Modality of Theism and Probabilistic Natural Theology: A Tension in Alvin Plantinga’s Philosophy.” Religious Studies 51:391–99.

Xu, Yingjin. 2011. “The Troublesome Explanandum in Plantinga’s Argument against Naturalism.” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 69:1–15.

Ye, F. 2011. “Naturalised Truth and Plantinga’s Evolutionary Argument against Naturalism.” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 70:27–46.