Weak Assertion

  • Eugeniusz Wojciechowski Hugo Kołłątaj Agriculture University of Cracow, Faculty of Forestry
Keywords: weak assertion; external negation; internal negation

Abstract

The paper contains references to a logical construction with two types of negation: an external (-) and internal (5) one, where the substitution of the dichotomous law of excluded middle (with the αω-α schema) by the trichotomy (αω¬αω±α) is proposed. With reference to an object belonging to a given universe and a given set of predicates some of them apply to it, whereas others do not. There can also exist such predicates which cannot be sensibly said to apply to it – they are indeterminate to it. What is proposed here is transferring these distinctions to a sentence calculus and devising a construction with a functor of weak assertion (+) as its primitive functor. This functor together with the functor of external negation allow an additional interpretation of the sentences falling into the third category described above (indirectness) whenever there is a need to express sentences referring to indirect states between the positive state and its negative counterpart.

References

Frege G.: Nachgellassene Schriften, hrsg. von H. Hermes, F. Kambartel, F. Kaulbach, 2. Auflage, Hamburg: Felix Meiner Verlag 1983.

Poczobut R.: Spór o zasad niesprzecznoci, Lublin: TNKUL 2000.

Wessel H.: Logik, Berlin: Deutscher Verlag der Wissenschaften 1984.

Wojciechowski E.: External and Internal Negation in Modal Logic, „Conceptus” 30 (1997), Nr. 76, s. 57-66.

Wojciechowski E.: Funktor słabej asercji, [w:] W. Suchoń, I. Trzcieniecka Schneider, D. Kowalski (red.), Argumentacja i racjonalna zmiana przekona, (Dialogikon XV), Kraków: Uniwersytet Jagielloński 2010, s. 85 94.

Wojciechowski E.: Negacja nazwowa a nieokreśloność i nieostro nazw, „Roczniki Filozoficzne” 58 (2010), nr 1, s. 281-290.

Wright G.H. von: Truth and Logic, [w:] tenże, Truth, Knowledge and Modality, Oxford: Oxford University Press 1984.

Wright G.H. von: Truth, Negation and Contradiction, „Synthese” 66 (1986), s. 3-14.

Zinoviev (Sinowjew) A.A.: Nichttraditionelle Quantorentheorie, [t. z rosyjskiego H. Wessel], [w:] H. Wessel (red.), Quantoren-Modalitäten-Paradoxien, Beiträge zur Logik, Berlin: Deutscher Verlag der Wissenschaften 1972, s. 179-205.

Zinoviev (Sinowjew) A.A., Wessel H.: Logische Sprachregeln, Berlin: Deutscher Verlag der Wissenschaften 1975.

Published
2020-06-09
Section
Articles