Preservation and Protection of the Cultural Heritage of Religious Purposes in Ukraine

Oleksandr Bilash; Tetyana Karabin; Mykhailo Savchyn

doi:10.18290/kip21102.1

Oleksandr Bilash Uzhhorod National University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1248-7798
Tetyana Karabin Uzhhorod National University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6538-5269
Mykhailo Savchyn Uzhhorod National University, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9551-1203

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18290/kip21102.1

Keywords: cultural heritage, religious cultural heritage, landmark, religious buildings, immovable cultural heritage

Abstract

The article deals with the current issues of preservation and protection of the cultural heritage of religious purpose in Ukraine at the modern stage and attempts to formulate legal problems and propose their solutions. The authors conclude that the proper preservation and protection of cultural heritage is fraught with the following legal obstacles. The first is the question of terminological certainty, the question of the unification of concepts. The second problem is the revision of the classification of landmarks into species and the separation of such species as religious landmarks (religious and church-life). The third problem is the lack of a generalized methodology for determining the modes of use and monitoring of the landmark depending on its type and kind, as well as the imperfection of legislation governing administrative liability for violations of cultural heritage.

References

Bilash, Oleksandr. 2013. “Problemy vidmezhuvannya nezakonnykh diy shchodo relihiynykh sporud abo svyatyn’ vid sumizhnykh skladiv zlochyniv.” Chasopys Kyyivs’koho universytetu prava 3:279-83.

Bilash, Oleksandr. 2021. “Strafrechtliche Verantwortung bei Rechtsverstosen gegen den Schutz der Sakralbauten oder Heiligtumer gemas der Gesetzgebung der Ukraine.” Kościół i Prawo 10 (23), no. 1:9-22. https://doi.org/10.18290/kip21101-1

Bondarenko, Olena, Hanna Putova, and Pavlo Koval’ov. 2008. “Znyshchennya pam’yatok istoriyi ta kul’tury Kyyeva. Styslyy ohlyad za 2007 rik.” Forum spasennya Kyeva. http://forumspaskiev.org.ua/databox/2007/05/17147.php [accessed: 10.09.2021].

Boyko, Oksana. 2008. “Tserkvy horyat’ v nezalezhniy Ukrayini, abo Bezkarnist’ vandaliv.” Elektronnyy resurs: Zakhidna analitychna hrupa. http://arhiv.orthodoxy.org.ua/uk/2008/03/19/14965.html [accessed: 03.10.2021]

Connolly, Anthony J., ed. 2015. Cultural Heritage Rights. London: Routledge.

Fedorova, Larysa D. 2015. “Pam’yatky istoriyi u zahal’niy systemi kul’turnoyi spadshchyny.” In Kul’turna spadshchyna v konteksti «Zvodu pam’yatok istoriyi ta kul’tury Ukrayiny», ed. Serhiy I. Kot, Halyna H. Denysenko, Hlib YU. Ivakin, et al. 486. Kyyiv: Instytut istoriyi Ukrayiny.

Kot, Serhiy I. 2009. “Pam’yatka.” http://www.history.org.ua/?termin=Pamiatka [accessed: 07.10.2021].

Kot, Serhiy I. 2015. “Istorychnyy dosvid ta aktual’ni problemy zberezhennya pam’yatok istoriyi ta kul’tury Ukrayiny.” In Kul’turna spadshchyna v konteksti «Zvodu pam’yatok istoriyi ta kul’tury Ukrayiny», ed. Serhiy I. Kot, Halyna H. Denysenko, Hlib YU. Ivakin, et al. 486. Kyyiv: Instytut istoriyi Ukrayiny.

Kot, Serhiy I. 2018. “Pro stan zberezhennya kul’turnoyi spadshchyny Ukrayiny.” In Informatsiyno-analitychni materialy do parlament•s’kykh slukhan’ «Stan, problemy ta perspektyvy okhorony kul’turnoyi spadshchyny v Ukrayini» 18 kvitnya 2018 r. 43. Kyyiv: Instytut istoriyi Ukrayiny NAN Ukrayiny.

Kovpanenko, Natalaya H. 1999. “Pam’yatky monumental’noho zhyvopysu.” In Aktual’ni problemy vyyavlennya i doslidzhennya pam’yatok istoriyi ta kul’tury. Part 2, 212-45. Kyyiv: Instytut istoriyi Ukrayiny NAN Ukrayiny.

Kryvets’ka, Liliya. 2019. Upravlinnya mistsevoyu kul’turnoyu spadshchynoyu v Ukrayini: ohlyad derzhavnoyi polityky, dzherel ta modeley finansuvannya: Bila knyha. L’viv: Laboratoriya mis’koho prostoru.

Mazur, Tamara V. 2021. Okhorona kul’turnoyi spadshchyny v Ukrayini: istoryko- y teoretyko-pravove doslidzhennya. Dysertatsiya na zdobuttya stupenya doktora yurydychnykh nauk. Kyyiv.

Myshchak, Ivan M. 2015. “Pravove rehulyuvannya protsesu formuvannya y napovnennya Derzhavnoho reyestru nerukhomykh pam’yatok Ukrayiny.” Naukovi zapysky Instytutu zakonodavstva Verkhovnoyi Rady Ukrayiny 2:15-20.

Piddubna, Victoriya F. 2013. “Shchodo pidstav nabuttya mayna relihiynymy orhanizatsiyamy.” Teoriya i praktyka pravoznavstva 2. http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/tipp_2013_2_10 [accessed: 28.09.2021].

Rubanovs’kyy, Kyrylo, ed. 2019. Analiz problem u zakonodavchomu rehulyuvanni zberezhennya ta upravlinnya kul’turnoyu ta pryrodnoyu spadshchynoyu v Ukrayini. Ivano-Frankivs’k: Ahentstvo z rozvytku pryvatnoyi initsiatyvy.

Slipchenko, Nataliya. 2001. “Inventarizatsiya mystets’kykh tvoriv u pam’yatkakh arkhitektury.” Pam’yatky Ukrayiny: istoriya ta kul’tura 4:130-33.

Tokman, Volodymyr V. 2014. “Problemy zberezhennya ta zakhystu kul’turno-relihiynykh tsinnostey Ukrayiny.” Analitychna zapyska. Natsional’nyy instytut stratehichnykh doslidzhen’. http://old.niss.gov.ua/articles/1434/ [accessed: 25.09.2021].

Tsivolas, Theodosios. 2014. Law and Religious Cultural Heritage in Europe. Germany: Springer International Publishing.

Tsivolas, Theodosios. 2019. “The Legal Foundations of Religious Cultural Heritage Protection.” Religions 10 (4):283. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel10040283

Yepifanov, Oleksandr V. 2017. “Problemy udoskonalennya normatyvno-pravovoho rehulyuvannya okhorony kul’turnoyi spadshchyny u konteksti konstytutsiynoyi modernizatsiyi.” Naukovi zapysky Instytutu zakonodavstva Verkhovnoyi Rady Ukrayiny 2:34-39.

Yepifanov, Oleksandr V. 2018. Konstytutsiyno-pravovi zasady okhorony kul’turnoyi spadshchyny: problemy teoriyi ta praktyky. Dysertatsiya na zdobuttya stupenya kandydata yurydychnykh nauk. Kharkiv.